Talk:Sorority Life

Merging page with Sorority Life on Facebook makes sense only if the game is no longer available on MySpace. -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 05:03, August 12, 2011 (UTC)


 * Myself, if merging, I would do it like this: Sorority Life on Facebook -> Sorority Life. Does that make sense? - Adan Aileron (talk) 17:13, August 13, 2011 (UTC)


 * On the assumption that that means leaving "Sorority Life" as the surviving page, I agree. But as long as there is still a version of the game on MySpace, about which someone who has experience of it can write, merging would be disadvantageous (by possibly misrepresenting the MySpace version), so I await the promoter's response telling us what possible advantage there is in merging two pages that have different functions. Wiki has no limit on the number of articles on a wiki. -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 04:20, August 14, 2011 (UTC)


 * I feel that this page really has no purpose as of now and should be merged with the Facebook for the time being. It is unknown if the versions on these sites are the same. However, if someone could verify what differences there are between the other versions, then this page should stay, linking ( adding links to the articles for each site) and noting the differences between the versions.  Z mario  09:57, August 14, 2011 (UTC)


 * I see. Zmario doesn't know whether there are differences in the games. Then clearly it's wrong to say "this page really has no purpose". One page describes a Facebook game and the other page links to that and mentions that MySpace has a version and can link to a page about that if anyone writes one: the current pages have different functions. It seems to me that it's the proposed merger that "really has no purpose as of now" except reducing the number of articles, which is not required by anybody and is slightly counterproductive. If someone manages to find and write about the MySpace version and it's the least bit different from the Facebook version, any merger would just have to be undone. Leave it as is, until we find out. Indeed, "if someone could vertify what differences there are between the other versions, then this page should stay, linking ..." - but until someone does verifies one way or the other it should stay, so as not to risk making a lot of work if there are differences. Zmario should continue adding to that great tally of thousands of edits, mostly constructive and clearly adding value to the wiki. -- Robin Patterson (Talk) 13:34, August 15, 2011 (UTC)


 * Thank you Robin, for taking the time to voice your opinion - I'm glad someone has taken the time to do that on this Wiki. I believe this page should serve as a disambiguation between the articles of Sorority Life - Facebook, Myspace, Hi5, Tagged, etc. At this point, I'm not sure if any current users play the game on these other social websites, so that is something to look into. Once again, Robin, thanks for taking the time to discuss this issue. At this point, I really can't see why it should be merged anymore!  Z mario  15:37, August 15, 2011 (UTC)