Herzog Zwei (ヘルツォーク・ツヴァイ Herutsuōku Tsuvuai ) (German: Herzog Zwei (German pronunciation: [ˈhɛɐ̯tsok ˈtsvai]) "Duke Two") is a real-time strategy video game developed by Technosoft for the Sega Mega Drive/Genesis home console. It was published in Japan by Technosoft in 1989 and in North America and Europe by Sega in early 1990. It is the sequel to Herzog, which was released only in Japan for the MSX and PC-8801 personal computers in 1988.
Herzog Zwei combined the fully real-time, fast-paced, arcade-style action gameplay of Technosoft's own Thunder Force series with a fairly easy-to-grasp level of strategy gameplay. It differed significantly from both turn-based strategy and real-time tactics, and is the earliest example of a game with a feature set that falls under the contemporary definition of modern real-time strategy. Along with a single-player mode against a computer opponent, it featured a split-screen two-player mode where both players are in action simultaneously and there are no pauses while decisions are taken, forcing players to think quickly while on the move. Though the player only controls one unit, a transforming mech, the manner of control foreshadowed the point-and-click mechanic of later games. It introduced much of the genre conventions, including unit construction and resource management, with the control and destruction of bases being an important aspect of the game, as were the economic/production aspects of those bases.
Upon release, the game received little mainstream recognition, and its novel approach to strategy gameplay polarized critics who were uncertain about what to make of it. It was generally well received by Japanese and European critics, with Computer and Video Games recognizing that its fully real-time, fast-paced gameplay set it apart from other strategy games at the time, while The Games Machine found its mixture of strategy and shoot 'em up elements to be unusual but refreshing. Reactions from North American critics, however, were generally negative, with Electronic Gaming Monthly criticizing it for being too complex, judging it as a flawed shooter rather than a novel strategy game, and giving it some of its lowest review scores for a Genesis game.
Years after its release, the game eventually gained a cult following. It has since been considered one of the best two-player Mega Drive/Genesis games, and has been listed among the best games of all time, by Electronic Gaming Monthly, IGN and Next Generation. It has been credited with laying the foundations for the real-time strategy (RTS) genre, predating and influencing the genre-popularizing Dune II. It is also retrospectively considered a precursor to the multiplayer online battle arena (MOBA) genre, which uses a similar formula of each player controlling a single command unit in one of two opposing sides on a battlefield. Herzog Zwei has been listed as one of the most important games ever made by 1UP, while GameSpy listed it as one of the most underrated games of all time.
|Computer and Video Games||82%|
|Electronic Gaming Monthly||17 / 40|
|Famitsu||29 / 40|
|Mega Drive Advanced Gaming||85%|
|Sega-16||10 / 10|
|The Games Machine||75%|
Upon release, Herzog Zwei was not very commercially successful and received little mainstream recognition, due to its lack of marketing, relatively early release on the Mega Drive/Genesis platform, and non-arcade genre on what was considered an arcade-oriented game console. Upon its 1990 release in North America, Electronic Gaming Monthly (EGM) harshly criticized the game for being too complex and judged it as a flawed shooter rather than a novel strategy game. They gave it an average rating of 4.25 out of 10, or 17 out of 40 overall, based on a panel of four individual reviewers giving it scores of 4, 6, 4, and 3, out of 10. The game received some of the lowest scores the magazine had ever handed out to a Genesis game; 3 out of 10 was the lowest score any Genesis game had received from EGM reviewers up until 1993, and Herzog Zwei was one of only six Genesis games to have received this score up until then. In Japan, the game was generally well received by Famitsu, which gave it a score of 29 out of 40. Famitsu compared it to Nectaris and Famicom Wars, but noted that Herzog Zwei distinguished itself with its simultaneous, two-player, real-time gameplay.
The game was generally more well received by European critics. In the United Kingdom, Warren Lapworth reviewed the game in the March 1990 issue of The Games Machine magazine, giving the game a 75% score. He criticized the title as "one of the silliest" names he had seen for a video game, but described the game itself as an "unusual product," a console strategy game with shoot 'em up style gameplay, stating, "Whether it's intended to get strategists to consider buying the console or to broaden the horizons of trigger-happy lunatics, I don't know. Either way, it's quite refreshing and can be quite addictive in two-player mode, fierce rivalry developing between friends." In the April 1990 issue of Computer and Video Games, reviewer Paul Glancey gave the game an 82% score. He described it as "a game of conquest between two commanders in real time" and recognized that what "sets it apart from other strategy games is that everything happens in real time. Both players are in action simultaneously and there are no pauses while decisions are taken so you have to think on the move or die." He noted that the command icons are "fairly easy to grasp" and concluded that it is a game that helps establish the Mega Drive as a "real" computer rather than "just a machine for immobilised arcade players." Its highest rating from a British magazine was from Mega Drive Advanced Gaming, which gave it an 85% score. In France, the game was reviewed in the November 1990 issue of the Joystick magazine, where reviewer JM Destroy gave the game a 78% score. The game was particularly well received in Germany, where critics referred to it as simply Herzog 2, with Power Play magazine giving it an 80% score in its April 1990 issue, while Play Time gave it an 85% score in its June 1991 issue.
Long after its release, the game gained a cult following and achieved some popularity. David Filip of Allgame gave the game a score of 4 out of 5 stars, describing it as "one of the first" and "one of the best" strategy video games on home consoles and as "a fine cure for those days when you want a different kind of RTS to control." Daniel Thomas of Sega-16 gave it a score of 10 out of 10 in 2004, describing it as "very probably the finest videogame you've never played" and as the Genesis console's "finest hour." Lawrence Wright of Insomnia gave the game a score of 5 out of 5 stars in 2008. GameSpot users have given Herzog Zwei an average score of 8.8 out of 10, as of 2009 and 2014.
It is often found on several "best of..." lists of video games, owing to its precedence in the real-time strategy genre, as well to the increasing understanding of finer points of its mechanics. It was featured in the "Top 100 Games Ever" list of Electronic Gaming Monthly, in the November 1997 issue which ranked it at #43 (by a different editorial line-up from years earlier), and in the January 2002 issue which ranked it #52. The February 1999 issue of Next Generation ranked it at #39 in its list of 50 best games of all time. It has also been featured in IGN's "Top 100 Games of All Time", in the 2003 list which ranked it at #62, and in the 2005 list which ranked it #95. In 2003, GameSpy listed the game as one of the 25 most underrated games of all time. 1UP included the game in its "Essential 50" list of "The Most Important Games Ever Made".
The U.S. game release packaging art was executed by veteran San Francisco game box illustrator Marc Ericksen, who had previously done the art for Thunder Force II, and was invited back by Sega for this image, as it was considered a 'sister' game to TFII. A sequel was planned for Sega's 32X platform, but with the subsequent failure of that console, so, too, died the plans for a third Herzog title. With Technosoft closing its doors in 2001 and the status of the intellectual property being unknown, the future of the series is likely sealed.
Herzog Zwei went on to influence future RTS games, particularly Dune II (1992), the producers of which acknowledged Herzog Zwei as an influence, as well as Warcraft (1994), Command & Conquer (1995), Starcraft (1998), War of the Rings (2003), and Brütal Legend (2009). Future Cop: LAPD (1998) featured a Precinct Assault mode that was similar to Herzog Zwei. Total Annihilation (1997) and its spiritual successor Supreme Commander inherited the concept of a large robotic command vehicle which is used to construct and command an army. However, Total Annihilation and Supreme Commander are controlled in similar fashion to traditional real-time strategy games; unlike in Herzog Zwei, the command vehicle in those games is mainly nothing more than a particularly powerful and versatile unit.
Scott Sharkey of 1UP states that, besides the original Herzog, the 1988 game Modem Wars was possibly "[t]he closest predecessor" to Herzog Zwei, but that it "was fairly primitive and abstract by comparison," that earlier such games lacked the ability to construct units or manage resources which made them "much more tactical than strategic," and that the slower processors and modems made the ticks "so long that the games were practically turn based".
The roots of the popular multiplayer online battle arena (MOBA) genre, also known as the action RTS genre, has been traced back to Herzog Zwei, which used a similar formula, where each player controls a single command unit in one of two opposing sides on a battlefield. Destructoid cited Herzog Zwei as "one of the world's first MOBAs." In 2008, GameAxis Unwired considered DotA to then be the closest modern equivalent to Herzog Zwei, but noted that, while DotA gives the player control over a fully customizable command unit with RPG elements, it severely limits or removes the player's ability to produce and command other friendly units, whereas Herzog Zwei has a fully customizable command unit with RPG elements that the player has full control over, while commanding an army to go into battle with rather than mindless drones that respawn at set intervals.
In 2004, a mod was created for Unreal Tournament 2004 attempting to recreate Herzog Zwei. In 2008, Guilty Gear 2: Overture used strategy gameplay similar to Herzog Zwei. On November 8, 2012, Carbon Games released AirMech, a MOBA game that is considered a more direct, spiritual successor of Herzog Zwei. It features modernized graphics and added gameplay mechanics, such as online multiplayer. The game has been released under a free-to-play model, and is available from Carbon Games, Steam, and the Google Chrome Web Store.
- Lapworth, Warren (March 1990). "Herzog Zwei". The Games Machine (28): 50. http://amr.abime.net/review_23961. Retrieved 4 February 2012.
- Brown, Fraser (January 15, 2013). Like Macross without the drama. Retrieved on January 19, 2013
- Greg Lockley (June 3, 2014), MOBA: The story so far, Market for Home Computing and Video Games
- Andrew Groen (March 7, 2012), Ask GR Anything: What's a MOBA?, GamesRadar
- Herzog Zwei, Sega-16 Review by Daniel Thomas (2004)
- Sharkey, Scott. Essential Top 50: Herzog Zwei. 1UP.com. Archived from the original on 2004-09-13 Retrieved on 2007-09-27
- Glancey, Paul (April 1990). "Mean Machines: Herzog Zwei". Computer and Video Games (101): 103. http://amr.abime.net/review_27759. Retrieved 4 February 2012.
- Are Real Time Strategy Games At Their Peak?. GameSpy (May 9, 2001). Retrieved on December 14, 2014
- Ian Erickson. Game of The Week: Herzog Zwei. GameSpy. Archived from the original on 2014-12-14 Retrieved on 2011-03-31
- EGM Top 100. Kisrael.com. Retrieved on 2011-06-01
- videogames|powerlist. kisrael.com. Retrieved on 2011-06-01
- IGN's Top 100 Games of All Time. Top100.ign.com. Retrieved on 2011-06-01
- IGN's Top 100 Games. IGN.com. Retrieved on 2009-01-09
- Bruce Geryk. A History of Real-Time Strategy Games. GameSpot. Archived from the original on April 27, 2011 Retrieved on March 31, 2008 “Early computer strategy games adhered firmly to the turn-based concepts of their board game ancestors, where—by necessity—players had time to plan their turns before their opponents had a chance to move. Real-time strategy changed all of that so that games would begin to more closely resemble reality: Time was limited, and if you wasted yours, your opponents would probably be taking advantage of theirs.”
- Clarke-Willson, Stephen (August 18, 1998). The Origin of Realtime Strategy Games on the PC. The Rise and Fall of Virgin Interactive. Above the Garage Productions. Archived from the original on 2014-12-14 Retrieved on 30 January 2012
- The Making of... Dune II. 'Edge'. Next-Gen.biz (December 9, 2008). Retrieved on July 27, 2011 “Herzog Zwei was a lot of fun, but I have to say the other inspiration for Dune II was the Mac software interface. The whole design/interface dynamics of mouse clicking and selecting desktop items got me thinking, ‘Why not allow the same inside the game environment? Why not a context-sensitive playfield? To hell with all these hot keys, to hell with keyboard as the primary means of manipulating the game!”
- Herzog Zwei (Genesis). 25 Most Underrated Games of All Time. GameSpy (September 2003). Archived from the original on 2004-07-21 Retrieved on 4 February 2012
- Herzog Zwei at Allgame via the Wayback Machine
- "Electronic Gaming Monthly's Buyer's Guide". Electronic Gaming Monthly: 46. 1993.
- Lawrence "NFG" Wright (January 4, 2008), "Herzog Zwei", Insomnia
- JM Destroy (November 1990). "Herzog Zwei". Joystick (10): 102. http://amr.abime.net/review_44262. Retrieved 4 February 2012.
- Mega Drive Advanced Gaming, issue 5, p. 63
- "Konsolen Spiel: Herzog Zwei". Play Time (1): 116–7. June 1991. http://translate.google.co.uk/translate?sl=de&tl=en&u=http://www.ninretro.de/game-4-2397.html. Retrieved 3 March 2012.
- "Herzog 2". Power Play: 121. April 1990. http://www.kultpower.de/powerplay_testbericht_extern.php3?im=herzog2.jpg. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- Raze, issue 5, pp. 58-59
- Sega Power, issue 23, p. 53
- Sega Pro, issue 18, p. 66
- Herzog Zwei Reviews. GameRankings.com. Retrieved on 2009-01-04
- Herzog Zwei for GEN. GameSpot. Archived from the original on 2009-06-28 Retrieved on 2009-01-04
- IGN's Top 100 Games. Top100.ign.com. Retrieved on 2011-06-01
- Whizzer (June 10, 2002). History of RTS Games: Part One. GameSpy. Retrieved on 2011-03-31
- The History of Command & Conquer. NowGamer. Archived from the original on 26 June 2011 Retrieved on 5 September 2011
- Schafer, Tim (2009-10-14). Battle Time. Double Fine. Retrieved on 2009-10-15
- GameAxis Unwired, p. 52, December 2008, SPH Magazines, ISSN 0219-872X
- Alex Kierkegaard (January 4, 2008), "Guilty Gear 2 -Overture-", Insomnia
- Review: Guilty Gear 2: Overture (Microsoft Xbox 360), Diehard GameFan